When Separate Could Have Been Equal: Jamila Minnicks' "Moonrise Over New Jessup" and the Integration Question We're Still Asking

There's a moment in Jamila Minnicks' stunning debut "Moonrise Over New Jessup" where Alice Young steps off a bus in 1957 Alabama expecting to encounter the familiar signage of segregation, "White Only" and "Colored", only to discover something extraordinary. New Jessup is an all-Black town where residents have not only rejected integration but have built something remarkable: a thriving community that operates entirely on its own terms.

Reading about New Jessup in 2025 feels like encountering an alternate timeline, one where Black folks said "we don't need to be where we're not wanted" and created spaces so vibrant, so economically robust, and so culturally rich that the question wasn't whether white people would accept them, it was whether they even wanted acceptance in the first place.

The Road Not Taken

Alice falls in love with Raymond Campbell, whose clandestine organizing activities challenge New Jessup's longstanding status quo as he works with the National Negro Advancement Society, a group that promotes separation over racial integration. This fictional organization mirrors real historical debates that were happening across Black communities in the 1950s. While the NAACP and other civil rights organizations were fighting for integration, other voices were asking a fundamental question: Why are we fighting to join institutions that never wanted us when we could be building our own? As The New York Times noted, "The novel delves smartly into the distinction between the fight for equal rights and the fight for integration." This distinction is crucial, and it's one that reverberates through Black communities today. Equal rights and integration are not the same thing. You can have one without the other.

New Jessup represents the path of true separate but equal—not the lie that was peddled during Jim Crow, but the vision of autonomous Black communities that could govern themselves, educate their own children, and build wealth within their own borders. The people of New Jessup have no interest in integrating with the white community in Jessup. They want to become a separate municipality—electing their own town council, collecting their own taxes, and running their own schools.

What We Gained, What We Lost

Integration undoubtedly opened doors that had been slammed shut for generations. It gave Black children access to better-funded schools, Black professionals access to previously whites-only institutions, and Black families opportunities to live wherever they could afford. The legal victories of the civil rights movement dismantled the formal structures of segregation and created the framework for the progress we've achieved.

But integration also came with casualties that we're still calculating today. When Black schools were closed or merged with white schools, we lost Black principals, Black teachers, and educational environments where Black excellence wasn't questioned but expected. When Black businesses lost their captive customer base as integration allowed Black consumers to shop anywhere, many of those enterprises died. When ambitious Black professionals could finally work at white corporations, some of the energy that had been channeled into building Black institutions was redirected elsewhere.

Alice's dilemma in "Moonrise Over New Jessup"—balancing her support for Raymond's separatist organizing with her desire to protect their community from upheaval—mirrors the tension many Black communities faced during this period. Do you fight to preserve what you've built, or do you risk it all for the promise of something better?

The New Jessup Question Today

Right now, in 2025, we're living through what feels like a systematic attempt to erase Black progress. We're watching Black leaders being forced out of key governmental positions, witnessing the dismantling of programs designed to support our most vulnerable community members, and seeing deliberate efforts to whitewash Black history in our schools. It's enough to make anyone feel defeated.

But here's what Alice and Raymond's story teaches us: we've been here before, and we've always found a way.

When Alice stepped off that bus into New Jessup in 1957, she wasn't just entering a town—she was walking into a vision of what Black self-determination could look like. The people of New Jessup didn't wait for permission to thrive. They didn't beg for a seat at someone else's table. They built their own table, served their own feast, and created a community so vibrant that it became a beacon for others.

Walk through certain neighborhoods in Atlanta, Detroit, or Washington D.C. today, and you'll see what modern-day New Jessups look like. These are spaces where Black-owned businesses line the streets, where HBCUs anchor the local economy, where Black cultural institutions define the community's identity. But you'll also see the pressures these communities face—gentrification that pushes out longtime residents, economic forces that make it difficult for Black businesses to compete, and systemic barriers that seem designed to fragment our progress.

The questions Raymond Campbell was asking in 1957 are the questions we must answer today: How do we build and maintain Black economic power when the systems seem rigged against us? How do we create educational institutions that serve our children when our history is being erased from textbooks? How do we develop political power that can't be diluted when our voices are being systematically silenced?

A Clarion Call: The New Jessup is Now

Friends, the New Jessup isn't just a fictional Alabama town from 1957. The New Jessup is wherever we are, right now, building something beautiful in the face of forces that want to tear us down.

The New Jessup is the Black teacher who refuses to let the erasure of our history stand, who finds creative ways to teach our children about their heritage despite the restrictions. The New Jessup is the Black entrepreneur who opens a business on a block where others see decay, bringing jobs and hope to a community that banks have redlined. The New Jessup is the Black family that chooses to send their child to an HBCU, investing in institutions that were built for us, by us.

The New Jessup is the collective of Black artists who create platforms for our stories when mainstream media won't tell them. It's the Black-owned credit union that provides loans when traditional banks say no. It's the community garden that brings fresh food to a food desert. It's the mentorship program that wraps our young people in love and high expectations when the world tells them they're not enough.

We are living in times that test our resolve, but let me remind you of something: we are the descendants of people who built Tulsa's Black Wall Street from nothing. We are the children of folks who created over 50 all-Black towns across America when this country said we couldn't govern ourselves. We carry in our DNA the wisdom of people who looked at exclusion and said, "Fine, we'll build our own."

The Vision We're Building

Every time we choose to support a Black-owned business, we're building New Jessup. Every time we invest in our HBCUs, we're fortifying New Jessup. Every time we create spaces where Black children can see themselves reflected in excellence, we're expanding New Jessup. Every time we build networks of mutual aid and support, we're strengthening New Jessup.

The beauty of Minnicks' vision is that it shows us integration and Black self-determination aren't opposing forces—they're complementary strategies. We can work within integrated systems while simultaneously building our own. We can fight for our rightful place in America while also creating spaces that are undeniably, unapologetically ours.

Today's New Jessups might not look like a single geographic community. They might be digital networks connecting Black professionals across industries. They might be educational cooperatives that supplement what our children aren't getting in traditional schools. They might be investment circles that pool our resources to buy back the block. They might be creative collectives that control our own narratives.

The Time is Now

The forces trying to erase us think they can break our spirit by dismantling our progress. They think they can discourage us by removing our representatives, defunding our programs, and whitewashing our history. They're wrong.

Every attack on our progress is also an invitation to innovate. Every door they close forces us to build our own entrance. Every program they defund creates an opportunity for us to develop solutions they never could have imagined.

Alice and Raymond chose love, community, and self-determination in the face of uncertainty. They chose to build something beautiful even when the future was unclear. They chose to invest in their own vision of what Black life could be, rather than waiting for someone else's permission to thrive.

We have that same choice. Right now. Today.

The New Jessup is calling us to stop waiting for systems to change and start building our own. It's calling us to stop hoping for acceptance and start creating spaces so magnificent that the question becomes whether we want to let others in. It's calling us to remember that we are not just survivors—we are builders, creators, visionaries who have always found a way to make a way.

The moonrise over our New Jessup is happening right now. The question is: Are you ready to step into the light?

The False Choice

Perhaps the most profound insight from Minnicks' novel is that integration versus separation was always a false choice. Based on the history of the many Black towns and settlements established across the country, Jamila Minnicks's heartfelt and riveting debut is both a timely examination of the opposing viewpoints that attended desegregation in America and a celebration of Black joy.

The real question isn't whether integration was right or wrong—it's how we move forward with both the opportunities integration created and the understanding that Black communities need spaces, institutions, and economic systems that are by and for us. We can appreciate the doors that integration opened while also recognizing that some doors should never have been closed in the first place.

New Jessup represents possibility. It shows us what happens when Black folks have the resources, the autonomy, and the vision to build something entirely their own. It reminds us that integration was never supposed to be about abandoning Blackness to gain acceptance—it was supposed to be about having choices.

Today's New Jessups might look different from Minnicks' fictional Alabama town. They might be digital communities, creative collectives, financial networks, or educational initiatives. They might exist within integrated spaces rather than separate from them. But the core principle remains: Black people deserve to have options, including the option to build something beautiful, successful, and entirely our own.

As we continue to navigate these challenging times, "Moonrise Over New Jessup" offers us more than entertainment—it offers us a blueprint. It shows us what happens when Black people refuse to let external forces define their possibilities. It reminds us that our ancestors didn't just survive—they created, they built, they thrived.

Minnicks has given us a vision of Black joy that exists not in spite of adversity, but because of our refusal to let adversity have the last word. New Jessup represents the truth that has sustained us through every attack on our progress: we don't need permission to be great. We never did.

So let this be our rally cry: The New Jessup is wherever we decide to plant our feet and build something beautiful. The New Jessup is wherever we choose love over fear, community over isolation, creation over destruction.

The moonrise is happening. The question is not whether we'll survive these dark times—we will, because we always have. The question is what we'll build in the light of this new dawn.

---

What do you think? In 2025, are we still asking the same questions Raymond Campbell was asking in 1957? How do we balance integration with the need for Black spaces and institutions? Share your thoughts in the comments below.