"Not Another Witch Story": How Blood Moon Rewrites Black Girl Magic

There's this quiet expectation in fantasy literature: when Black girls show up, they're witches. Root workers. Conjurers. Practitioners of something the industry keeps calling "dark" and "mystical." And look, I get it. That archetype comes from somewhere real. Our history is full of ritual and spiritual inheritance. The conjure woman, the root worker, the woman who knows which herbs heal and which words hold power? She's ancestral. She matters.

But she's also become a loop. Another spell, another coven, another Black girl who has to save the world before she even gets a chance to figure out who she is. The trope has turned into expectation, and expectation, when it goes unchecked, becomes a cage.

That's why Britney S. Lewis's Blood Moon feels like such a breath of fresh air. It's not another witch story. It's something bigger. Something that reaches back to the griots, those first storytellers who knew how to weave truth through the impossible. They understood that sometimes you need the supernatural to show you what's right in front of your face. Blood Moon does that same work, letting ancestral rhythm pulse beneath its contemporary skin without announcing itself.

And then there's Mira Owens. She's human, grieving, curious, and suddenly caught in the middle of a war between vampires and werewolves. What gets me about Mira is that Lewis lets her be curious without being clueless. She pieces things together in real time, making the kinds of imperfect calculations actual people make when reality starts bending.

Because here's something that's been bothering me about YA: why do so many young heroines, especially Black ones, have to perform this dance of willful obliviousness? Why can't they see what the reader spotted three chapters ago? I think it's this unexamined belief that teenage girls, particularly Black teenage girls, need to be rescued from their own intelligence. That wisdom has to be earned through maximum suffering.

It's infuriating because real Black girls don't get that luxury. They're forced into acute awareness early. They learn to read rooms, read bodies, read threats with precision. They develop situational literacy as a survival mechanism. And then fiction wants us to believe they can't spot the obvious? Mira doesn't do that. She's allowed to be smart and still make mistakes. She's allowed to figure things out.

That tension Mira lives in, caught between a war she didn't start, navigating worlds she's still learning exist, that resonates. Because being a Black girl often means navigating multiple realities at once. There's the mundane: school, family, first love, all the ordinary machinery of growing up. But there's also the mythic: being burdened with representational weight, expected to perform resilience like it's instinct, tasked with translating yourself across spaces that were never designed with your humanity in mind.

You're always between. Between belonging and exile. Between survival and actually getting to discover who you are.

Lewis refuses to let Mira collapse into symbol. She gets to be messy: vulnerable, impulsive, brave, in love (and what a gift that is, letting Black girls be foolishly, beautifully in love in genre fiction), and maybe even a little bit magical herself. But not in the ways we've come to expect.

It's rare to see Black girlhood braided together with vampires, family secrets, romance that doesn't apologize for existing, and supernatural warfare that treats our heroine as participant rather than pawn. In a world that still has a meltdown when a Black actor plays a fictional character once imagined as white, Lewis's book feels like quiet rebellion. Like she's saying: Black girls can exist in any mythology we want. We're not limited to one kind of magic.

And that ending. That cliffhanger. The kind that makes you close the book, stare into space, and immediately start counting down to the sequel.

Maybe that's what makes Blood Moon special. It invites us to linger between fear and fascination, between what's real and what's hiding just beneath the surface. It's haunting without being heavy, thrilling without sacrificing tenderness. And just in time for Halloween, it gives us a story that's dark enough to quicken your pulse while reminding us that Black love and Black storytelling have always been their own form of magic.

Not the kind that needs permission. Not the kind that fits neatly into one box. The kind that insists we can be anything—even when the whole supernatural world is watching.

---

Question for the readers: What's a Black YA story that changed how you see fantasy—or how you see yourself? Was it a character, a plot twist, a single line that stuck with you?